Revolution and reality

Green fields, water in plenty, palatial houses, good looking and hard working people that’s the stock image of India’s most prosperous province Punjab. The shining example of agricultural success touted as the “Green Revolution”. However, the reality is less romantic than the image that has been projected for the last four decades. Climate change and environmental pollution have ganged up to challenge the wits and nerves of these hardy people and for the first time it seems odds are heavily stacked against them.

The latest findings show that Punjab is witnessing a slowdown in agricultural production. In comparison to 1980s when the growth rate was 5 percent the 1990s saw a decline where the growth was registered at 2.4 per cent, in the 21st century it has become a meagre 1.9 percent.

The decline is significant when you realise that the area under cultivation for two of the major crops –wheat and rice—has been steadily increasing every year. For example the paddy cultivation was done in 227 thousand hectares (th ha) in 1960 in 2006 it was being cultivated in 2642 th ha, while wheat was being cultivated in 1400 th ha in 1960 in 2006 it had grown to 3468 th ha. The use of high yield varieties (HYV) of rice and wheat has seen an upward trend too. In 1970 while 69 per cent of the wheat sown was HYV and 33 per cent of the paddy too was of the same genre by 2006 in both the cases the use of HYV had reached 100 per cent.

Excessive use of fertilizers, water and pesticides coupled with increased area under wheat and paddy cultivation created a sudden boom we now know as Green Revolution. However, the same factors have now become the cause for its decline. The HYVs have been using certain elements of the soil at the expense of other nutrients. This has led to severe deficiency of nutrients in the soil. Even while wheat and paddy cultivation area is up the varieties of these two crops have come down drastically. Prior to Green Revolution Punjab was producing 41 varieties of wheat but now it grows only a couple of varieties. As the area under wheat and paddy cultivation has increased it has brought down the cultivation of jowar, bajra, maize, sugarcane, groundnut, pulses, rapeseed, barley, mustard and sunflower. Lack of crop rotation and consistent use of HYV does not offer the soil any chance to regenerate itself. The loss of certain nutrients is compensated with the help of standard fertilizers and pesticides increasing toxicity in the soil and permanently perpetuating the nutrient deficiency.

Indiscriminate use of tube wells have led to a situation that today the land of five rivers has a demand of 4.38 mham (Million hectare metres) of water while the availability is at 3.13 mham making it a water scarcity zone. Out of 137 blocks in Punjab, 103 are over exploited, 5 blocks are critical and only 25 are in safe category.

Small land holdings are another problem, one million or 69 per cent of the land holding in the state are less than 4 hectares in size. Compared to all India figures this size may look healthy but the level of mechanization and resource intensive agriculture being practised for the last four decades makes the holding size uneconomic. It has led to a situation where on an average a farmer bears a debt of Rs. 41,000.      

Caught between mounting costs of production and debts and declining per hectare productivity the farmers in Punjab are waking up to a chilling reality that green revolution is actually a red herring, a fleeting moment of prosperity leaving disaster in its wake.

About indiadynamic

mediaperson worked for TWI, TVI, Dainik Bhaskar, UTV and Hindustan Times in all the divisions print, TV, radio and internet
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Revolution and reality

  1. Ajay S Jasra says:

    Keshav, the problem is that of mind set. We have never taught to conserve and use the water judiciously. Look at Rajasthan and Gujarat; water scarcity has always been part of their history; therefore; they have rich tradition of Baolis, and use of water is judicious in their culture. You won’t see a single baoli in Punjab. Even in Delhi (I am attending daily morning visit to yoga camp in Chhattarpur farms) water is bought at almost same rate of CNG; since money has been paid for it; the residents don’t feel guilty for the criminal use of water while watering their plants and grass spread across couple of acres. The need is there to change the mind set first, dear friend … KEEP GOING AND BEST OF LUCK…

  2. lakshman says:

    What you say and prove may sure be a cause of concern, but was there any other way forward then, way back when India had to depend on the alms of the western nations to feed its (even then) millions facing droughts and famines. For food security, green revolution was an answer, may be not 100 per cent appropriate but sure effective enough. If there are millions still going hungry, the problem is one of inequitable distribution that is more shocking (to me) than this soil degradation due to use of fertilisers. Agriculture and agriculturalists getting robbed in the country is not anything new, has been happening since times immemorial — terms of trade have always been adverse to farming, more so even today. And how dangerously it is getting manifested — farmers suicides that have ended up as mere events that the media sometimes condescends to show its horror (is it mock show), and then promptly in the next frame on prime time TV concentrate on and compete with the other channels the burning national problem of Aishwarya Rai’s growing weight and or Sania Mirza’s ind-pak marriage match test. A good first attempt to focus on this issue which has many facets and complicated, as complicated as the many actors and players make it to be. Kudos. Keep at it and do bring us the other aspects as authoritatively as you have done the first post. Cheers

    • indiadynamic says:

      Sir what good that strategy did if it failed in a short span of 4 decades. Its like using steroids to win Mr. Universe contest and then dying of cacenr or worse. In the life of a nation things aren’t done in such haste or with such short term gains in mind. That is what i think your comments are welcome.

  3. Dhiraj Singh says:

    Congrats and welcome to Blogistan!
    We need blogs like yours to apprise the children of the digital revolution about what happens when the euphoria of a revolution takes over all critical evaluation of it…
    Thanks for the very thought-provoking piece… look forward to more!!!

  4. aparna says:

    Hey Keshav, this story or shall we say the third-eye vision of India’s Green Revolution requires to be pointed out. Though neither uncommon not unknown, now staying green calls for a new approach. Whether one looks for local culture and eco-practices or waits for men to birth self replicating cells in a test tube… what i would like to see on the ground is sustainable, affordable, eco answers. what next… bests.

    • indiadynamic says:

      Thanks teacher, all this is due to your training. I would like to bring stories of success and of course challenges on this blog. please keep visiting once in a while

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s